Big Ships vs Small Ships? Pros and Cons
By: Cruise Scoop Team
Cruises are one of the most popular ways to vacation, supersized ships are trying to keep up with record breaking demand. As of 2024, they have doubled in size since 2000. With ships getting larger and larger, you have to ask yourself, is being on a larger ship better? Clearly, the cruise lines must feel they are going to be popular otherwise, why build them bigger? What is really the difference between cruising on big ships vs small ships. We will review the pros and cons of a big ship vs a small ship, so you can decide what is right for you!
In this article, we will compare 2 large ships (Royal Caribbean’s Icon of the Seas and Norwegian’s Viva) versus 2 small ships (SeaDream Yacht Clubs’s SeaDream I and Windstar’s Star Pride) as a basis for discussion.


The Pros of a Large Ship
The Cons of a Large Ship
If you would love the pros of a large ship but can do without the cons, well there is another option for you. Many of the cruise lines now have a “ship-within-a-ship” concept. These exclusive areas offer an elevated level of privacy, personalized service, and premium amenities. For a detailed comparison of the “ship-within-a-ship” offering, please read this article. You will benefit from the large ship feel while eliminating many of the cons.

Windstar - Star Pride

SeaDream Yacht Club - SeaDream I
The Pros of a Small Ship
The Cons of a Small Ship
We have had the pleasure of traveling on SeaDream Yacht Club’s Seadream I and it was simply superb. Truly a relaxing and yet adventurous experience. Our cruise visited many quaint ports including St. Barts and we even had the opportunity to jump off the Watersports Marina into the ocean for a swim. It was exhilarating.
Summary
Certainly with larger ships, the ship itself is the destination. With all of the amenities, activities, entertainment onboard, you will never have to leave it. You can just enjoy your time on the ship comfortably. There is something for everyone to enjoy together or separately. On a smaller ship, there will be many opportunities to wind down and relax when underway. In port, you will have the opportunity to participate in various water sports or venture into port and explore the destination.
It comes down to what kind of cruise you would like. One full of activities and entertainment onboard or more of a relaxing and intimate experience. As you can see each one has its own set of pros and cons. You have to decide what kind of experience you would like to have!
Still can’t decide? Let REVEL Around The World help you.
Enjoy your travels !


Lots of opportunities for physical activity: The larger the ship the more decks and stairs to climb. Why take the elevator when you can take the stairs and feel great. You don’t need to visit the fitness center to get exercise, you can get up early and walk/run around the ship before anyone is awake. You can explore the ship and get physical exercise at the same time, you can walk to your hearts content, on each floor, up the stairs and around the promenade. The beauty being it won’t feel like exercise because there are so many sights to see!
No hustle and bustle: There is very little hustle and bustle on the ship as there are few people on it. It is relatively quiet and tranquil, with plenty of opportunities for moving about, but generally low-key. No one is rushing to get to the pool or hot tub before the crowds arrive or rushing to get to a lounge chair before they are booked. There is no need, it will probably be available.
More Intimate Relationships: It is no surprise that you will see the same faces at every turn. You will have opportunities to get to know other passengers more intimately if you choose. You will see them more often, exchange stories of the day or dine with them at every occasion.